Designing a Pedagogically Consistent Rubric for High School Writing and Science: Integrating NGSS, Common Core, and Knowledge Processes

Abstract

Since 2022, with the launch of ChatGPT, artificial intelligence has been a hot topic, especially in education. Focusing on the educational environment, much has been asked about the implications of the popularization of AI tools. Drawing from teaching and research experiences, this study shares initial observations on a research project that aligns with these considerations. The research proposes to work on generative AI (GenAI) to provide feedback to high school students in the United States through an educational platform called CGScholar. To do so, GenAI is used in a very guided way, following a specific rubric to provide feedback to students’ writing that is consistent with the curriculum. Thus, in designing the research, a rubric is essential to measuring the quality of the GAI feedback provided. To do so, the authors of this proposal worked on a specific rubric that combined the content expected by students both from the Generation Science Standards (NGSS) and The Common Core Writing Standards, since these are national guidelines for high school students’ writing and science development. Thus, in this paper we focus on the ongoing research, mainly on the process of creating a rubric that corresponds, in terms of pedagogy, to the knowledge processes part of the multiliteracies pedagogy by Kalantzis and Cope (2015, 2023), which involves experiencing, conceptualizing, analyzing and applying. Therefore, we pshare the research experience and its early results, especially considering that using a rubric in GAI environments can be a crucial pedagogical decision.

Presenters

Vania Castro
Student, Teaching Assistant Professor, University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, Illinois, United States

Raigul Zheldibayeva
Lecturer, Zhetysu University, Kazakhstan

Ana Karina de Oliveira Nascimento
Professor, Department of Foreign Languages, Universidade Federal de Sergipe, Brazil

Details

Presentation Type

Paper Presentation in a Themed Session

Theme

2025 Special Focus—Learning from Artificial Intelligence: Pedagogical Futures and Transformative Possibilities

KEYWORDS

Rubric, Generative AI, NGSS, Common Core, Knowledge Processes