Embodied Argumentation in Action: St. Francis of Assisi and Theological Persuasion

Abstract

This paper explores the role of St. Francis of Assisi in embodied argumentation through action and its implications for contemporary Catholic practice. Examining his theological approach within the framework of visceral argumentation, a concept developed by Michael Gilbert, and narrative engagement, this study investigates how The Little Flowers of St. Francis function as a mode of theological persuasion beyond conventional textual argumentation. Analyzing key narratives from The Little Flowers, the research identifies how St. Francis’s lived example served as a form of theological discourse, embodying a persuasive model rooted in humility, service, and radical faith. Furthermore, the study evaluates the impact of Franciscan spirituality on broader Catholic traditions, emphasizing its enduring influence on environmental stewardship, social justice, and modern ecclesial movements. Utilizing a mixed-method approach that incorporates historical, hermeneutical, and rhetorical analysis, this study situates Francis’s life and teachings within the discourse of embodied theology and performative argumentation. Framing St. Francis as both a historical and contemporary figure of spiritual persuasion, this research contributes to ongoing discussions on the intersection of religious narrative, embodiment, and theological praxis, shedding light on the ways in which lived action continues to shape theological and spiritual discourse in the Catholic tradition.

Presenters

Loris Isabettini
Student, PhD Candidate, University of Windsor, Ontario, Canada

Details

Presentation Type

Paper Presentation in a Themed Session

Theme

2025 Special Focus—Fragile Meanings: Vulnerability in the Study of Religions and Spirituality

KEYWORDS

Embodied Argumentation, Franciscan Spirituality, Visceral Argumentation, Religious Persuasion